Please upgrade your web browser

These pages are built with modern web browsers in mind, and are not optimized for Internet Explorer 8 or below. Please try using another web browser, such as Internet Explorer 9, Internet Explorer 10, Internet Explorer 11, Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Apple Safari.

Challenges Among Military-Trained And Non-Military-Trained Personnel In The Workplace

Leadership & Management

Do you work with a team of military-trained personnel and non-military who are constantly disagreeing and arguing? Do you feel as if you do not understand each other? Do you feel as if you cannot get anything accomplished because you spend more time arguing than achieving a mutual goal? The President’s Veterans Employment Initiative “created a one-stop website resource for Federal veteran employment information [which] is designed to ensure veterans, transitioning service members, and their families receive accurate and consistent information regarding veteran employment in the Federal Government (USAJOBS)." The initiative of recruiting and training veterans is great. However, we also need to train both military-trained personnel and the non-military-trained personnel on how to work as a team and understand each other.

Prior Military Personnel: The transition from active duty to the civilian workforce can be difficult. Your leadership, training, dedication, sense of duty and technical skills are admirable and in high demand. You were trained to follow, give orders, and lead others. Unfortunately, if you do not have a leadership role in the civilian workforce, you may feel frustration and may not feel you are ready to give up power or authority. You could have a difficult time transitioning from being the leader to being led. You might consider yourself the subject matter expert, using the “how we used to do it” or “how it used to be done.” You might get frustrated because the civilian personnel do not move at your same speed and sometimes they do not understand what you are saying. Remember, the “transition and readjustment process does not mean you give up being a warrior, but rather [that you] learn to dial up or down your warrior responses depending on what’s happening around you, always adapting to the environment you find yourself in (Hoge 2010)." A few recommendations for a more suitable transition and relationship with your peers include:

  1. Speak with the person with whom the miscommunication exists and with whom you conflict. If that does not work, then:
  2. Speak with your supervisor to discuss your frustrations. If you do not trust or feel comfortable speaking with your supervisor, then:
  3. Seek guidance from the Office of Human Resources or -
  4. Visit your nearest Veteran Service Office

Useful sources
A) Seeking employment. Visit the FEDSHIREVETS at http://www.fedshirevets.gov/ OR https://www.usajobs.gov/
B) Further your education. You may use your GI Bill to pay for school. Visit http://gibill.va.gov/
C) Understand yourself. Once a Warrior, Always a Warrior. Visit http://onceawarrior.com/
D) Recognize your possible emotional distress. Visit http://www.veteranscrisisline.net/Default.aspx

Civilian Personnel: You might think that the prior-military employees are cold and authoritative. You might not understand their terminologies and despise their unwillingness to adapt to the civilian workforce. You might think that prior-military personnel expectations are unrealistic. They work at a faster pace and expect you to do the same. This might frustrate you because everyone works at a different pace. In addition, you might feel resentful thinking that prior-military personnel demand special treatment, respect and recognition, something you think you are forced to give. Get to know your peers, including former military personnel. A few recommendations to a more suitable situation include:

  1. Speak with the person with whom you are having trouble. Tell the person how you feel. You might be surprised to find out that both of you are frustrated with each other. If that does not work, then:
  2. Speak with your supervisor to discuss your frustration. If you do not trust or feel comfortable speaking with your supervisor, then:
  3. Reach out to the Office of Human Resources. They might have readjustment training for both prior-military and civilian personnel. If they don’t, request it.
  4. Seek outside help (e.g. a career counselor).

Upper Management: Recognize the root of the problem and identify trends. There will always be conflict at the workplace, but identifying the root of the problem could help you create a system to develop your team and minimize collateral damage within your organization. Some of the most common complaints among teams of prior-military and civilian personnel include:

A) Communication: Prior-military personnel are accustomed to using military time (e.g. 1300, 1600, 2200 versus 1 pm or 6 am). They might still use military words or acronyms (e.g. battle planning, battle field, battle rhythm). They also go by the book; if it’s not written, it does not exist. The challenge with this approach is that if the civilian employees are not accustomed to using those terminologies, or do not understand the concepts, they could be resentful and frustrated, especially if the prior-military personnel are not receptive to using civilian terminologies. Develop a culture to address conflict and miscommunication issues.

B) Career and Personal Development: If you are not doing so already, meet one on one with your personnel. Identify who among your team needs more coaching and coach them on how they could be more successful in the organization. “Society believes that a warrior should be able to transition to home and live a “normal” life, but the reality is that most of society has no clue what it means to be a warrior (Hoge 2010)." One-on-one coaching could help you to get to know your employees and better help them.

C) Bias: Your role as a supervisor is to lead and influence. Make sure you don’t play favorites with your employees. Most importantly, you need to be confident in your leadership and work ethics. If you think that your employees are working against you or feel threatened by their initiative and skills, you will not lead well. Trying to show your employees “who is in charge” will not fix the issues. Do not hold on to knowledge in order to keep job security; instead, delegate to train and mentor your employees.

D) Seek Professional Help: You have a responsibility to your employer and your employees. If you have tried to build harmony among your employees and your attempts have been unsuccessful, consult with the Office of Human Resources for guidance. They might have a transition training program for both the prior-military and civilian personnel. They should be able to help you know what to expect when you hire prior-military personnel and how to help them work with you versus feeling like they are working against you. If the Office of Human Resources does not have a transitioning program for the military personnel, recommend starting one. You will be helping your current and future employees. A reason to recommend a transitioning program to HR is mentioned by Bonnie M. Vest: “the civilian and military cultures are in many ways directly oppositional to each other in terms of their values and structure, creating barriers to the reconciliation of the two (Vest 2012, 2)." Therefore, you can help your employees better if you understand both the civilian and the military culture. Remember, “most prior military personnel are more independent, but this may make it difficult to tolerate authority at work (Hoge 2010)." Your responsibility as a leader is to understand your employees, which will help you lead them better. A good start is the book Once a Warrior Always a Warrior by Charles W. Hoge: http://onceawarrior.com/

Jealousy, resentment, and miscommunication at the workforce will hinder your organization and development. Both the employer and the employee need to understand the best practices of working with a team of both prior-military and civilian personnel. We all have a responsibility to make our workplace a more enjoyable and stress-free environment. The initiative to end conflict and misunderstanding at the workplace starts with you and me.

References

Hoge, W. C., 2010, Once a Warrior Always a Warrior- Navigating the Transition from Combat to Home- Including Combat Stress, PTSD, and mTBI, Lyons Press. Website: http://onceawarrior.com/

USAJOBS, Welcome Veterans, https://www.usajobs.gov/Veterans

Vest, B. M. “I am a citizen solder” Negotiating civilian and military in the post 9-11 National Guard, State University of New York at Buffalo, ProQuest, UMI Dissertations Publishing, 2012. 3495234.

If you have comments or feedback about any article, please email your thoughts to info@acp-advisornet.org.

About the Author

Write an Article

We welcome articles on any subject that might help our veterans. Articles are especially useful in place of frequently similar responses, and can be linked in your replies.

Add an article